the newspaper
University of Toronto's Independent Weekly
thenewspaper@thenewspaper.ca
Saturday, February 4, 2012
the newspaper - University of Toronto's independent weekly
Wednesday, 26 May 2010 00:03

UTSU vs. Guess Who?

Written by  Diana Wilson
There is no question that there is ongoing tension between the University of Toronto Students’ Union (UTSU) and Antonin Mongeau, former president and current alumni chair of EFUT (U of T’s French club). Their strained relations reached a critical point on April 25 when UTSU Executive Director Angela Regnier sent an email to Mongeau asking him to “cease and desist any contact with staff and executive members of the University of Toronto Student’s Union effective immediately” because of his alleged “displays of hostility and aggression against staff and executive members of [UTSU].”

Mongeau played a controversial role in the recent UTSU elections. He posted a confrontational video on YouTube showing a Ryerson Students’ Union (RSU) exec campaigning on behalf of the Stronger Together slate. In reaction to the video, the UTSU election’s Chief Returning Officer issued 25 demerit points to the Change slate based on harassment from a “non-arm’s-length party.” This compelled Change to publicly distance themselves from Mongeau.

A few days after the cease and desist email was sent, UTSU held an open forum on the state of the Student Commons project in a University College classroom. Mongeau defied the cease and desist by attending the meeting. Forty-five minutes after the scheduled start of the meeting, outgoing UTSU President Sandy Hudson announced that it was cancelled due to “unforeseeable circumstances.” An attendance list went around to the approximately 35 attendees asking for their names, affiliated organizations, and email addresses. Then the meeting dispersed. Within half an hour, telephone calls went out to a select group of attendees to notify them that the meeting would reconvene immediately at the Graduate Students’ Union basement at 16 Bancroft.

Mongeau caught wind of the new location and entered the basement partway through the meeting. Campus police were contacted and a recess was called. Police came and talked to Mongeau privately before escorting him out of the building. The basement door was subsequently locked.

Regnier’s cease and desist request was not a formal injunction against Mongeau. It was not sent to him through UTSU’s lawyers, but was upheld by the campus police. UTSU refused to comment on their harassment claims. Campus police and the university administration have also officially declined to comment.

In the spirit of our Q&A issue, the newsmagazine hoped to provide a platform for UTSU to respond to Mongeau’s questions. Mongeau denies UTSU’s claims of harassment, stating that UTSU’s unwillingness to answer his questions is symptomatic of their opacity. the newsmagazine sent Mongeau’s queries to UTSU with a disclaimer that they do not represent the views of our paper and that the organization should take the opportunity to correct any possibly misleading information. UTSU President Adam Awad’s response: “I am not in a position to debate with Mr. Mongeau at this time.” (Note: The explanations in brackets following the questions were also written by Antonin Mongeau):

How much money was put into the Clubs Funding Rollover fund this year? (During the 2008-09 elections VP Internal & Services Adnan Najmi promised the establishment of a roll-over fund for clubs funding. He later confirmed that the fund was in fact operational beginning this year. The fund would presumably house any unused moneys from one year to increase the next year’s budget. Clubs are chronically underfunded, and the smaller ones have a tendency not to pick up their second and third instalments, meaning that of the purported $180K allocated for clubs, less than $100K actually went out the door. Where is the rest?)

Where will the Student Commons actually be?

If a democracy had a 100% incumbency rate, wouldn’t you say it needed drastic electoral reform to introduce more democratic accountability? (The incumbents have never lost an election since the CFS took over in 2002. No functioning democracy has a similar incumbency rate.)

How often does the UTSU use police to silence dissent?

What proof do you have that Antonin Mongeau is harassing you?

Given that Antonin’s attendance at UTSU meetings and events on University property has been sanctioned by both the police and the administration, how long can you continue to hide in the GSU basement?

Additional Info

  • Subtitle:

4 comments

  • Comment Link Nate Thursday, 08 July 2010 08:45 posted by Nate

    I highly doubt it, especially the way some of these questions are worded. They're hostile, and as I've stated before hostile questioning will only receive a hostile answer.

    At the same time, if an individual is not a member of any student union on campus (i.e. an actual student registered at the university) or is not a staff at any of these student unions, what business do they have meddling in the affairs of the student union? None.

    If they've clearly stated that you're not welcome, you don't continue to pop up. I speak the truth when I say that someone who continues to do that will be labelled a pariah and will only continue to be seen as such until there is some form of reconciliation

    On another note: What former student union execs are doing now is irrelevant to the issue.

  • Comment Link Antonin Wednesday, 16 June 2010 23:07 posted by Antonin

    Nate, I understand that The Newspaper did ask these questions respectfully, politely, and repeatedly. REPEATEDLY. (As did I).

    I didn't start interacting with the union by taping them on my blackberry, it graduated to that point after several years of emails, phone calls, and meetings. They simply refuse to give answers on the record. Anyone associated with campus media can confirm it.

    There is nothing in my videos which suggests I have ever acted untowards in their regards. I simply ask questions and they spazz out, because they are absolutely allergic to answering questions on the record, especially when those questions involve where the money goes, or even "do you go to this school?".

    And why do I have to tape them? Because if I don't, they fabricate even worse stories about me. See the Alice Wu episode from last year. I've done a lot of things, but I've never taped anyone surreptitiously. I'm pretty brazen about it. Watch the videos again, you'll see.

    As far as the Union booting me out of events, newsflash: didn't work. Or more accurately, only works on one building on campus: the GSU basement. You cannot book university facilities for broadly advertised events, and blacklist people. Despite Regnier's laughable efforts, this isn't Stalinist Russia. That bullshit ain't gonna fly, and I'll be at every event this year. Look for me, and you can even talk to me face to face, since I, unlike the Union, am always happy to answer questions. I'm also pretty friendly.

    All of these attempts to isolate me have failed catastrophically because they've earned the contempt of literally the entire school, minus those who are on the UTSU payroll, or auditioning for jobs at the CFS.

    Need proof? Ask yourself: What's Hadia up to these days? Sandy? Hamid Osman? Oh right, they're all shelling for the mothership. Keep it up with you facts-backwards postings and I'm sure you'll one day earn an A+ too.

    Forget the CFS bro, that shit it coming to an end.

  • Comment Link Nate Monday, 07 June 2010 08:53 posted by Nate

    * In regards to the statement "Of Course not", I meant to say "Of Course"

  • Comment Link Nate Monday, 07 June 2010 08:51 posted by Nate

    I must dispute the statement about the so-called "incumbency". While Mr. Awad and Ms. Sandhu were members of the 2009-2010 UTSU Executive Committee, it is inaccurate to state that they were incumbents as they were running for completely different positions than the ones they held in the previous term (Awad was the UA VP and was elected President, while Sandhu was the CL VP and was elected as Equity VP). In the same way, one would not state that a Lieutenant-Governor or any member of a US State Cabinet running for the position of Governor is an incumbent in the race to fill that position.

    In terms of the Student Commons and the Money issue, I'm sure if someone asked politely and respectfully, the Student Union would provide a satisfactory answer to those questions.

    In the case of dissent, I personally have had no problems voicing my concerns or comments directly the members of the executive. The problem is people who often have issues with the student union and are vocal about it, don't do it smartly. If someone was rude toward you, wouldn't you be turned off from listening to them or even consider their concerns? Of course not. Hostile questioning will only receive a hostile answer.

    Mr Mongeau's videos are evident enough of harassment. During the 2010 Spring elections, Mr. Mongeau was attempting to covertly film either ST campaigners and their supporters, and was doing so without verbal or written permission of those individuals, as well as clearly violating their privacy. While Mr. Mongeau could attempt to claim "Freedom of the Press", which he has every right to do under the Constitution Act, his actions appear to be done out of spite, rather than Journalism.

    I'm sure until Mr. Mongeau ends his harassment of the Student Union, its Staff, and its executives, his presence will probably not be welcomed at any Student Union function, open or otherwise.

Leave a comment

Make sure you enter the (*) required information where indicated.
Basic HTML code is allowed.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...